AI Benchmarking with GA4 Data: How to Set Smarter Performance Standards Using Machine Learning

In GA4, benchmarks help you set expectations around metrics like traffic, engagement rate, and conversions. However, benchmarks are often static or become outdated because they are  based on past performance or industry averages that may no longer reflect or are applicable to your current benchmark data. That is where we need the help of an AI. 

Instead of relying on one-size-fits-all standards, AI can analyze your historical GA4 data to build dynamic benchmarks that actually adapt with your business. Whether you're comparing campaigns, landing pages, or user segments, AI can spot patterns, group similar performers, and highlight unusual patterns or data regardless of their  good and bad. In this post, we’ll explore how you can use AI models to benchmark smarter, catch issues early, and make better decisions with your data. We’ll even walk through a real-world example and cover visualization tools and common pitfalls. Let’s dive in.

What Benchmarking Means in a GA4 Context

In the context of Google Analytics 4 , benchmarking refers to the process of comparing your website or app’s performance against a set of predefined standards or goals. These benchmarks serve as reference points to help you evaluate whether your digital strategies and efforts are driving results effectively.

There are two types of benchmarks.

• Internal benchmarks are based on your own historical data. For example, if your site averaged a 3% conversion rate over the past quarter, that figure becomes your internal benchmark for evaluating future performance. This method helps you identify improvements or declines over time within your own data sources.
  
• Industry benchmarks, on the other hand, are aggregated standards derived from competitors or peers within your sector. These allow you to assess how your performance stacks up against others in your industry. Google previously offered some of these through its Universal Analytics benchmarking reports, but this feature is currently limited in GA4.

We’re sharing this because the main focus here is internal benchmarks. We’ll slightly touch on industry specific benchmarking as well. 

If you want to further explore what benchmarking can do with your GA4 data, you can check out our previous blog post: Optimize GA4: Create Benchmarks for Better Forecasting

The Problem with Internal Benchmarking: Why We Need Smarter Help

Internal benchmarking is a useful starting point for evaluating your website performance. However, it has some significant limitations  especially as businesses grow, markets evolve, and user behavior becomes less predictable. Relying solely on internal benchmarks can quickly become a roadblock especially if you’re making future plans or decisions. Here’s why.

1. Historical Data Doesn’t Always Predict the Future

Internal benchmarks are based on your past performance. But what happens when market conditions shift, new competitors enter the space, or you change your marketing strategy?

• A conversion rate that was “normal” last quarter may be suboptimal today.
• Seasonal spikes or promotional campaigns can skew averages and make your benchmarks less reliable for long-term planning.

Without understanding all of this, internal benchmarks can lock you into outdated assumptions.

2. Manual Setup could be an outdatedInsights

Most internal benchmarks are either set up manually in spreadsheets or hard-coded into dashboards. Over time, they often become static metrics that don’t reflect real-time shifts in customer behavior, product offerings, or campaign performance. These benchmarks are rarely reviewed or recalibrated regularly. In short, your team may still be tracking to goals that no longer serve your actual business reality.

3. Lack of Personalization or Segmentation

Internal benchmarks often rely on averages across the entire website or customer base. This ignores nuance.

• Your mobile traffic might perform very differently from desktop traffic.
• New users may have completely different engagement patterns compared to returning customers.

Treating all traffic the same can hide underperformance or overperformance in specific segments, meaning you miss opportunities to optimize where it matters most.

4. Benchmark Blind Spots

Internal benchmarks offer no external perspective. You may be improving month over month, but are you keeping up with the industry? Are you outperforming  competitors or falling behind? You see,  without external or predictive context, internal benchmarks will leave you falling behind.

How to Start AI-Enhanced Benchmarking in GA4

Step 1: Set Up Reliable Data in GA4

The foundation of good benchmarking is clean, consistent tracking.

• Make sure GA4 is capturing the metrics you want to benchmark: user traffic, conversions, engagement rate, etc.
• Use custom events to track key events or conversion  actions (e.g., sign-ups, purchases). If you need help with this, you can check out our previous blog post on setting up custom events in GA4 with GTM. 
• Segment your data by device, channel, or audience type, this helps later when identifying performance differences.

Step 2: Export Your GA4 Data to Google Sheets

You can manually or automatically export GA4 data to Sheets.

Export reports manually from GA4. Include:

• Date
• Sessions
• Conversions
• Engagement rate
• Bounce rate
• Channel/source

For more detailed steps you can check out our blog post: Google Analytics 4 to Google Sheet: Export Data directly

Or use Google Sheets to directly export your GA4 data. Here’s how:

1. Open Google Sheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets 

2. Go to Extensions → Add-ons → Get Add-ons

3. Look up for “GA4” in the search bar and click on GA4 Reports Builder for Google Analytics™ or other GA4 add-on tool that will work for you, but in this example, we’re using GA4 - Reporting for Google Analytics 4

4. Follow the instructions on how to install. 

5. Once installed, click Extensions → GA4 - Reporting for Google Analytics 4  → Create new report

6. Set up the report, by:

• Report name
• Date range 
• Access the data source from what GA4 account and property
• Dimensions (e.g., Session Default Channel Grouping, Date)
• Metrics (e.g., Total Users, Engaged Sessions, Bounce Rate…)

7. Once you’re okay with the set up, click “Save and run report”

8. The report is created on a separate tab. A prompt will tell if it was successful or not. 

Step 3: Use Google Sheets + ChatGPT for AI-Lite Benchmarking

Once you have the data in Google Sheets, you can begin to layer in simple AI logic. Here's how:

Option A: Ask ChatGPT to analyze your Sheet. This is convenient if you have budget constraints. 

• You can directly upload your Google sheet to your preferred AI tool. Just make sure you’ve cleaned it for easy analysis.  For example, sort it by date, remove extra columns or rows which are not necessarily needed. This is just a way to ensure AI would understand raw data properly and this will give you a more accurate analysis.

• Use prompts and say: “This is 12 weeks of GA4 data from my site. Can you help identify anomalies, underperforming weeks, or patterns?”

• You can also ask: “What’s a reasonable (metric) benchmark based on this history?” “Can you summarize where I’m trending above or below my historical average?”

Option B: Forecast with AI

• Provide the AI with a weekly time series and ask:
  “Based on this data, can you forecast the next 4 weeks if current trends continue?”
• You’ll get an AI-generated projection without any coding or modeling.

Before We Wrap Up

We're working with relatively simple data here, and any insights generated by an AI tool will mainly depend on your specific business needs and goals. If you're open to paying a little extra, you can also use AI tools directly within Google Sheets. This can be more convenient, as there’s no need to download raw data and upload into a ChatGPT or GeminiI tool. While there are several generative AI Google Sheets add-ons available, we don’t have a specific recommendation at this time, but you can easily choose one that fits your budget and has positive user reviews.

Overall, the benchmark data you generate can serve as a valuable baseline to assess the effectiveness of your marketing channels over specific timeframes whether daily, weekly, or monthly. By identifying underperforming channels, you gain clearer direction for optimization efforts. We recommend exploring with different prompts, tools, and approaches to fully maximize generative AI tools. Additionally, consider configuring anomaly detection alerts within your GA4 account to proactively monitor deviations from your benchmarks and respond quickly to any unexpected changes.

FAQs: What Readers Might Still Be Wondering

1. What’s the best metric to start benchmarking with?
   Start with engagement rate or conversion rate. These metrics reflect both user interest and business outcomes, making them practical benchmarks for most websites.
2. How often should I update my AI benchmarks?
   A monthly review works well for most sites, especially if your traffic, content, or campaigns change frequently. For more stable sites, quarterly might be enough.
3. Is AI benchmarking only for large sites or enterprise teams?
   Not at all. Even small websites or solo marketers can benefit from using free tools to spot trends, forecast results, or identify underperforming segments.
4. What if I don’t know how to code?
   You don’t need to. Use Google Sheets for calculations and ask tools like ChatGPT to help analyze patterns or generate forecasts. You can also use Looker Studio to visualize trends and anomalies.
5. Will AI benchmarking replace traditional analytics?
   No, think of it as an upgrade, not a replacement. AI helps add context, spot patterns faster, and offer smarter recommendations. Traditional metrics still matter.
6. How do I explain these models to leadership or clients?
   Focus on outcomes, not math. Instead of explaining algorithms, say things like:

“Our engagement dropped 12% this month, which is below our rolling benchmark. The AI suggests mobile users had a slower load time,that’s our next fix.”

7. What’s a sign that my benchmarks or AI insights might be off?
   If results feel inconsistent, illogical, or don’t match reality, something’s off. It could be missing data, an outlier skewing averages, or just not enough history yet. Simplify your approach and rebuild with clean data.
8. Do I need historical data to start benchmarking?
   Yes, ideally, at least 8 to 12 weeks of data. The more clean, consistent data you have, the more accurate your baseline becomes. This helps the AI (or even your spreadsheet formulas) learn what's “normal” for your site.

Final Words

Benchmarking isn’t dead, it’s just evolving. With the power of AI, you no longer have to guess what's “good” performance or rely on stale industry averages. By applying machine learning to your GA4 data, you can uncover hidden trends, catch issues early, and continuously refine your standards based on real user behavior.

It doesn’t take a full data science team to get started. Just the willingness to experiment, ask better questions, and use the tools already at your fingertips. Whether you're building your first benchmark model or simply rethinking how you measure success, this is your chance to make your analytics work harder, and smarter, for you. Ready to raise the bar?

Thank you for reading!

‍We're always looking for ways to improve our Google Analytics 4 blog content. Please share your feedback so we can make it even better.